Plymouth’s Road Runner nearly died in a hallway argument at Highland Park, killed off by a stylist who swore no cartoon bird would ever wear his sheet metal. The man who saved it was a product planner named Jack Smith, a former Studebaker engineer who also helped create the GTX and who died recently at 94. He never claimed the idea as his own. Read on for how a $3,000 budget bomb beat every projection Plymouth had for it.
Somewhere in a hallway inside Chrysler’s Highland Park headquarters, a stylist named Dick Macadam jabbed a finger into the chest of an executive vice president and swore that no cartoon bird would ever wear his sheet metal. He meant it, and he had the rank to make it stick. By every reasonable measure of how corporate decisions actually get made, that should have been the end of the whole idea: no bird, no beep-beep horn, no stripped-down midsize with a big-block under the hood and a window sticker most factory workers could actually cover. The reason it was not the end comes down to a product planner most enthusiasts have never heard of, and the story of how he won that argument is better than the argument itself.
The Man Who Handed the Credit to Someone Else
That planner was John L. Smith, known to everyone at Chrysler as Jack, and he died recently at the age of 94. At the time the Road Runner was taking shape he was a manager for product planning on the Belvedere line, which is exactly the kind of job title that gets left out of the documentaries. What makes Smith unusual in an industry full of people happy to claim paternity for a hit is that he consistently refused to say the Road Runner was his idea. He credited his assistant, Gordon Cherry, every time he was asked. The car still would not exist without him, because coming up with a concept and getting it built are entirely different jobs inside an automaker.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
From a Studebaker Drawing Board to Detroit Stoplights
Smith did not arrive at Chrysler as a marketer. He trained as a mechanical engineer and worked at Studebaker before joining Chrysler in 1957, and during those Detroit years he ran a hopped-up Belvedere of his own on public streets. That detail matters more than it sounds. The Road Runner works as a product because somebody involved actually understood what a young buyer with limited money wanted out of a car, rather than guessing at it from a market research summary. In 1967 Smith had already helped create the Plymouth GTX as a direct answer to the Pontiac GTO, and he was involved in the Mod Top vinyl roof program that put floral patterns on Plymouth and Dodge hardtops.
The Letter Brock Yates Wrote in 1966
The specific spark came from outside the company. In 1966, journalist Brock Yates wrote to Bob Anderson, Chrysler’s new executive vice president of sales and marketing, with a proposal that reads like a recipe: take a midsize two-door, strip it down, make it cheap and light, and stuff in the biggest engine you have. Anderson wanted something to capture the youth market that Lee Iacocca had just proven existed with the Mustang. Smith and his boss Joe Sturm, then product planner for all of Plymouth, took Yates’s letter seriously enough to build a car around it. Anderson, incidentally, was the executive on the receiving end of that finger in the chest.
Under Fifteen Seconds, Under Three Thousand Dollars
Smith described the target in terms any drag strip regular would recognize: kids wanted big brakes, stiffer suspension and a four-speed on the floor, and his objective was a car that could run the quarter mile in under fifteen seconds at over 100 mph with a sticker under $3,000. Plymouth hit it. The 1968 Road Runner arrived with a 383 cubic inch V8 rated at 335 horsepower, borrowed heads and cam from the 440, a bench seat, rubber floor mats, and almost nothing else. The 426 Hemi sat on the option sheet for buyers who wanted to skip the pretense entirely. Base price landed under the $3,000 line, which was the entire point.
Why the Bird Was the Hardest Part of the Car
The bird was the hard part, and not only because of Macadam’s hallway ultimatum. Chrysler had to license the Road Runner character from Warner Bros., and the reported figures have become part of muscle car folklore: roughly $50,000 for the name and another $10,000 to develop a horn that made the right beep-beep sound. Corporate stylists hated the idea of paying to put a cartoon on a car, and from a pure design standpoint they had a case. From a product standpoint they were wrong. The bird gave a deliberately plain car an identity that a buyer could explain to his friends in three seconds, which is worth more than any amount of chrome.
The GTX Came First, and It Explains the Road Runner
Understanding the GTX makes the Road Runner make sense. The 1967 GTX was the upmarket approach: a 440 Super Commando making 375 horsepower as standard equipment, the 426 Hemi optional, plus the trim and interior appointments that justified the price. It was Plymouth’s gentleman’s express. Smith had helped build that car, learned what it did and did not sell, and then went the other direction entirely. Where the GTX added, the Road Runner subtracted. Both cars came from the same planner within roughly a year of each other, which is a remarkable range of judgment for one person to show inside a single division.
What Happened When the Cars Actually Reached Dealers
The market settled the argument. Plymouth’s internal projections for 1968 were modest, reportedly in the low thousands of units, and the car sold roughly 45,000 in its first year. The 1969 model roughly doubled that and took Motor Trend’s Car of the Year award, which is not a trophy stripped-down budget cars usually collect. Nearly six decades on, a documented Hemi Road Runner is a six-figure car and even a well-kept 383 four-speed commands serious money at auction. Jack Smith’s name appears on none of it.
Why Product Planners Deserve More Statues
It is worth sitting with what Smith’s job actually involved, because the muscle car era is usually narrated through designers, engine men and racers. Product planning is the unglamorous discipline of deciding which combination of existing parts, price points and marketing angles will produce a car people actually buy, and then defending that decision against everyone inside the building who would prefer something else. Smith did it twice in eighteen months, in opposite directions, and got both right. The GTX proved Plymouth could sell an expensive performance car. The Road Runner proved it could sell a cheap one to a completely different buyer without cannibalizing the first. Getting either one wrong would have cost the division real money, and getting the cheap one wrong would have taken the whole youth market strategy with it. Jack Smith never got a wing on a building or a plaque on a factory wall. Anyone who has ever heard that horn echo across a parking lot owes him a nod anyway. Share your thoughts in the comments below.
Republished by Blog Post Promoter
Related posts:
Muscle Car Fan Breaks 1/2 Million Followers
Plymouth Belvedere GTX 1967 to 1974
1970 Plymouth Hemi Barracuda
Muscle Car Classic: 1970s Plymouth Hemi ‘Cuda
Chrysler Hemi Power 3 of 5
Plymouth GTX 1967 images
Plymouth Belvedere RH2 1966 images
Man Stung by Mexican Super Bee
50’s-70’s American Street Racers. Where are they now?
Who is the Greatest Drag Racer of all Time? NHRA’s 50 Greatest
R.I.P. Thank you!!
I had a 68 !!
Been there had a 1970 R.R.
same here 440 4 speed 391 rear
Rest In Peace.
Jim Muldoon
I had a 69 383 4 speed
Thank you.
Rest In Peace, you had a vision and the world saw it and followed, inexpensive fun at a time we needed some, beep beep, if you owned one you’ll understand !
Well said.
My two favorite cars love these
Rest In Peace and mopar or no car!!!!!!!
One of the best muscle ever build,god bless
Great cartoon and a great man
Rip thank you
1969 GetX, 440, auto-2800 Stall converter, B&M quick shift valve body, 3.31 gears, Turbo mufflers.
RIP.
R.I.P. Jack And Thanx For The Rides…….
Thanks for the memories, I had a 69 Roadrunner and a 68 and 69 GTX , I would love to have any of those cars now.
RIP
Thank you for your vision
He put some excitement in the Mopar Family…. Rest in Peace…
Loved mine
lets go for a cruise and show people what a real car looks and sounds like
That b good but that car is long gon…I had it when I was 18. Can cruz in my b arracuda thoď
Corky Olson
His legacy will live on forever..
RIP and thank you!
R.
May he R.I.P.
“Plymouth Makes it”
69 roadrunner…. My favorite car
Some of the best Mopars ever produced…
Rest In Peace Dick Macadam….. Thanks for many memories and leaving those Fords and Chevies in a distant second place…..!!!
Thanks for the creativity! God bless
RIP, nice taste in car’s
Mopar fan had 2 roadrunners
when i saw this pic, it put a smile on my face….beep-beep!
Lord bless his family with peace and love through this time of sorrow. Amen
My two favorite cars are late 60’s Charger and Roadrunners and the Challenger! Had both Charger and Challenger but wish I would have bought a RR!!
R.I.P. You left such an amazing gift to the world, thank you!
Rest in peace they need to bring it back in his honor
Sad