Ford almost named the Mustang Cougar — then handed the name to Mercury, which built a 428 Cobra Jet muscle car with it. MotorWeek revisits the 1968 Cougar, the Car of the Year pony car cousin that still flies under the radar today.
Video: MotorWeek on YouTube.
Ford almost never got to call its pony car the Mustang. For most of its development, the car that would redefine affordable performance in America carried a different name on its badges and in its design studios: Cougar. Only a late push from Ford’s ad agency — and a market research report that found “Mustang” tested better than every other name on the list — pulled the cat emblem off the car at the last minute. Ford already had the badges made. The name didn’t die, though. Mercury picked it up, built a pony car cousin on a stretched Mustang platform, and by 1968 turned it into something the Mustang itself never quite managed: a genuinely upscale muscle car that still had teeth.
That’s the car MotorWeek’s Joe Ligo revisits in a feature on the 1968 Mercury Cougar, and it’s a car that deserves more attention than muscle car history usually gives it. The Cougar won Motor Trend’s Car of the Year for 1967, a distinction the Mustang never collected, and it did it by refusing to be just a badge-engineered twin. Mercury gave it a longer wheelbase, a softer ride, hidden headlights, and a formal vinyl roof option — then backed all of that comfort with some of the same big-block muscle that was turning heads over at Ford and Chevrolet dealerships that same year.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Name Ford Gave Away
The story of how “Cougar” ended up on a Mercury instead of a Mustang is one of the stranger near-misses in Detroit history. Throughout the Mustang’s development in the early 1960s, Ford’s design team under Gale Halderman worked under the Cougar name, and the corral-style grille emblem that eventually became the Mustang’s running horse was, for a long stretch, sketched as a crouching cat. Ford had cougar badges and nameplates ready to go into production. Other names were floated too — Torino, Puma, Cheetah, Allegro — but Cougar was the clear favorite deep into the process.
It was market research, not styling, that killed it. Ford’s ad agency tested a shortlist of names on consumers, and Mustang won decisively, reportedly scoring higher because people associated it with wide-open spaces and freedom rather than a predator. Lee Iacocca signed off on Mustang, the car launched in April 1964, and the rest is automotive legend. But Ford didn’t throw the Cougar name away — it handed it to Mercury, which had been looking for a way to get its own version of the pony car phenomenon onto showroom floors without simply rebadging a Mustang. Mercury’s engineers took the Mustang’s unibody platform, stretched the wheelbase by three inches, softened the suspension, and gave the car hidden headlights and sequential turn signals the Mustang never offered. The Cougar launched for 1967, and immediately out-styled and out-trimmed the car whose name it had inherited.
What Made the 1968 Cougar More Than a Dressed-Up Mustang
For 1968, Mercury kept building on that formula. The base Cougar came with a 302-cubic-inch two-barrel V8 rated at roughly 210 horsepower, but Mercury added three stronger engines to the option sheet that year: a 302 four-barrel at around 230 horsepower, a 390 four-barrel, and — for buyers who wanted real muscle under that formal sheet metal — a 428 Cobra Jet four-barrel making 335 horsepower. Transmission choices ran from a three-speed manual up through an optional four-speed and Mercury’s own Merc-O-Matic automatic, so a Cougar could be configured as anything from a comfortable boulevard cruiser to a genuine quarter-mile threat.
Mercury pushed the formula even further with the GT-E package, a short-lived option that paired the Cougar’s formal good looks with one of Ford’s biggest big-block V8s. Fewer than 400 GT-E Cougars left the factory that year, making it one of the rarest performance variants of the entire late-1960s muscle car era — rarer, in fact, than most of the limited-run Mopars and GM specials that get far more attention from collectors today. The GT-E never sold in volume because Mercury never marketed the Cougar as a drag-strip weapon the way Plymouth hammered the Road Runner or Pontiac hammered the GTO. It was there for buyers who wanted the option quietly available, not splashed across a brochure.
The XR-7 trim was where the Cougar’s split personality really showed. It added a walnut-toned dash, competition-style gauges, a leather-wrapped steering wheel, and a console-mounted shifter — the kind of interior appointments you’d expect from a Thunderbird, not a muscle car. MotorWeek’s own description of the Cougar as the “mature” muscle car gets at exactly this: Mercury wasn’t trying to out-drag-race the GTO or the Road Runner on raw intimidation. It was selling buyers who wanted genuine performance without giving up comfort, quiet, and a interior that looked like it belonged in a luxury car. Production for 1968 topped 113,000 units, and a limited-edition Dan Gurney XR-7G added trim and lighting upgrades tied to Mercury’s Trans-Am racing program that same year.
A Legend That’s Finally Getting Its Due
Ask Cougar owners why the car still matters and you’ll hear some version of the same answer: it never tried to be a Mustang, and that’s exactly the point. Viewers responding to MotorWeek’s feature describe Cougars that have been in their families for decades — a mother’s first car out of college with a 289 and four-speed, a father’s 1967 that’s still in the garage after twenty years, a car bought new in the late 1960s and only sold once the kids were grown. More than one commenter called the Cougar an underrated classic that deserves a spot on the wishlist ahead of the Mustang it’s always been compared to.
Mercury also leaned on the Cougar’s connection to Trans-Am racing to build credibility the showroom car didn’t automatically have. Driver Dan Gurney’s involvement with the factory-backed racing program lent his name to the limited XR-7G package, and while that car wasn’t built to the same aggressive spec as the GT-E, it tied the Cougar’s image to a motorsports pedigree the Mustang was simultaneously building for itself in the same series. For a brand that had spent most of the 1960s selling comfortable family sedans, that association mattered — it told buyers the Cougar wasn’t just a Mustang in a nicer suit, it was a car Mercury was willing to race.
That underrated status is part of what makes the 1968 Cougar interesting today. Mustangs and Camaros from the same era have become expensive, heavily documented collector cars with price guides and registries tracking every option code. The Cougar, built on the same bones with arguably better engineering and a nicer interior, has spent decades in the Mustang’s shadow on the collector market. For buyers chasing genuine late-1960s muscle car performance without competing against Mustang-level demand, that gap hasn’t gone unnoticed.
Why the Cougar’s Story Still Resonates
There’s something fitting about a car that exists only because its own name got rejected somewhere else. The Cougar didn’t inherit the Mustang’s spotlight, its sales numbers, or its place in pop culture, but it inherited something arguably more useful: the freedom to be its own car. Mercury used that freedom to build something the Mustang never quite managed to be — a genuine muscle car that didn’t ask you to give up comfort to get there. The hidden headlights, the sequential taillights, the walnut-trimmed XR-7 cabin, and a 428 Cobra Jet under the hood for buyers who wanted it all added up to a formula that still holds up more than half a century later.
That gap is starting to close. Auction results over the past several years have shown Cougar values creeping upward as more collectors discover what Mercury actually built in 1968 — a car with Mustang-level performance potential, a nicer cabin, and genuine rarity in its top trims. For now, clean 428 Cobra Jet and GT-E cars remain a fraction of the price commanded by comparably equipped Mustangs and Camaros, which is exactly the kind of gap muscle car buyers spend years looking for.
Watch the full video above and let us know your thoughts in the comments.











