Hemi or LS6? 1970 Chevelle SS 454 vs Hemi ‘Cuda

Hemi or LS6? Few arguments at a car show last longer than this one. In 1970 Chevrolet put the LS6 454 into the Chevelle SS, and Plymouth put the 426 Hemi into the brand new […]

Hemi or LS6? Few arguments at a car show last longer than this one. In 1970 Chevrolet put the LS6 454 into the Chevelle SS, and Plymouth put the 426 Hemi into the brand new E-body ‘Cuda. Both engines were rated on the old gross horsepower scale, both were built for buyers who wanted the biggest number the factory would print, and both are still compared at every cruise night today. This post lays out what each manufacturer actually claimed, what each car was built to do, and what a serious buyer should confirm before putting real money down. The figures come from published references, mainly the Wikipedia articles on the Chevelle, the Barracuda and the Hemi engine. Anything we could not verify has been left out on purpose.

The rules of the fight: gross horsepower

Before comparing numbers, remember what the numbers are. In 1970 both companies quoted SAE gross horsepower, a rating taken from the engine on a stand without the full load of accessories and exhaust it would carry in a car. By 1971 Chevrolet was already publishing both gross and net figures for every engine in the Chevelle line, which tells you how quickly the yardstick was about to change. So when we say 450 versus 425, we are comparing two marketing-era ratings from the same year, not two dyno sheets from the same dyno. That matters to hardcore fans, who know that a gross rating is a starting point for an argument, never the end of one.

1970 Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 LS6

Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 01
Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 01 by RL GNZLZ (CC BY-SA 2.0), via Wikimedia Commons

The 1970 Chevelle received sheet metal revisions that gave the body a more coke bottle look, and the interior was redesigned as well. The Super Sport package came in two flavors, the Z25 option with the 402 cubic inch engine still marketed as the SS 396, and the new Z15 option with the 454 cubic inch big block. The Z15 454 was available only with SS equipment. The base 454 was the LS5, rated at 360 bhp, and it could be ordered with cowl induction.

⚑ Featured Gear
Start Car Conversations →

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The one that started the arguments was the optional LS6. According to Wikipedia, the LS6 used a single 800 CFM Holley four barrel carburetor and produced 450 bhp at 5600 rpm and 500 lb-ft of torque at 3600 rpm. It was a solid lifter, high compression version, and the same source notes that Chevrolet claimed 450 bhp gross for it. Wikipedia lists 4,475 LS6 Chevelles built, and that is a figure worth quoting with its source attached rather than treating as gospel, because production totals in this hobby get repeated for decades without anyone checking the original paperwork.

Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 02
Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 02 by RL GNZLZ (CC BY-SA 2.0), via Wikimedia Commons

The LS6 story also has a short ending. The 1971 Chevelle was announced with the LS6 as a regular production option, but it was dropped early in the model year, and Wikipedia states that no official records indicate any 1971 Chevelle was assembled with it. GM had also told its divisions to design engines for regular, low octane, lower lead or unleaded fuel, which pushed compression ratios to 9:1 and below. Engines from 1970 and earlier ran about 10.25 to 11.25:1 on the high performance side. In other words, 1970 was the peak year for this exact kind of engine, and the Chevelle SS 454 LS6 is the car that shows it.

1970 Plymouth Hemi ‘Cuda

1970 Plymouth Hemi 'Cuda Ecurie Chrysler France
1970 Plymouth Hemi ‘Cuda Ecurie Chrysler France by Mr.choppers (CC BY-SA 3.0), via Wikimedia Commons

Plymouth’s answer arrived in a new body. The Barracuda began on April 1, 1964 as a fastback version of the Valiant, which made it a frugal family car with a big rear window. By 1970 that was history. The all new third generation was styled by John E. Herlitz and built on a shorter, wider version of Chrysler’s B platform called the E-body, which it shared with the new Dodge Challenger. The redesign removed all previous commonality with the Valiant, and the fastback was deleted, so the car came only as a coupe or a convertible.

Three versions were offered for 1970 and 1971: the base Barracuda, the luxury oriented Gran Coupe, and the sport model, the ‘Cuda. The ‘Cuda’s standard engine was a 383 rated at 335 hp SAE gross. The option list read like a menu for hardcore buyers: the 340 cubic inch AAR ‘Six Barrel’ with three two barrel carburetors at 290 hp, a 440 four barrel at 375 hp, the 440 Six Barrel at 390 hp, and the 426 Hemi at 425 hp. Wikipedia notes that the E-body’s engine bay was larger than the earlier A-body’s, which made it possible to fit the 426 Hemi, and that the 440 and Hemi cars received upgraded suspension components and structural reinforcements to help put the power on the road.

The Hemi itself was not new to the world in 1970. Chrysler developed the 426 Hemi for NASCAR in 1964 and produced it through the early 1970s. The Hemi engine article adds that because of its power, and because Chrysler had shown NASCAR chief Bill France that a DOHC version was in the works, it was banned from NASCAR races, though it stayed legal in certain drag racing classes. That history is why a Hemi ‘Cuda carries so much weight in the hobby: it is a race engine story as much as a street car story.

Side by side: what the factory claimed

  • Chevelle SS 454 LS6: 454 cubic inches, 450 bhp gross at 5600 rpm, 500 lb-ft at 3600 rpm, one 800 CFM Holley four barrel, solid lifters, high compression.
  • Hemi ‘Cuda: 426 cubic inches, 425 hp SAE gross, E-body platform, upgraded suspension and structural reinforcements on Hemi and 440 cars.
  • Paper advantage: the Chevelle by 25 horsepower, and Chevrolet is the only side here with a published torque figure in our sources.
  • Chassis idea: the Chevelle is a mid size car with a long muscle car history, the ‘Cuda a brand new pony car shell built around a bigger engine bay.

Notice what is missing from the list: a verdict. Gross horsepower, a single torque figure and a platform description do not tell you which car is quicker in a given situation. Tires, rear axle ratio, transmission choice, weight and the driver decide that, and the published numbers for those vary by individual car.

Racing: what the ‘Cuda actually did

If you want proof that a rating is not a result, look at the racetrack. Swede Savage and Dan Gurney raced identical factory sponsored AAR ‘Cudas in the 1970 Trans-Am Series. The cars qualified for three pole positions but did not win a race, and the highest finish was second at Road America. Away from the American circuits, four 1970 Hemi ‘Cudas were raced by Chrysler France from 1970 until 1973. The works team director, Henri Chemin, drove the first car and then sold it to his friend and privateer J. F. Mas, who raced it for two more years. According to Wikipedia that Hemi ‘Cuda won four French Group 1 class championships, three on track and one in hill climbing. Those are real results, and they show the car could succeed when the setup and the circuit suited it.

What a hardcore buyer should verify

These two cars sit near the top of the market, which means fakes, clones and tribute builds are a real concern. Hardcore buyers already know this, but it is worth saying plainly. First, ask for documentation: the build sheet or broadcast sheet, the original window sticker if one survives, and any dealer paperwork. Second, check that the engine and body numbers agree with the paperwork for that exact model year, and be wary of any seller who cannot explain a gap. Third, remember that an SS 454 Chevelle and a ‘Cuda are not the same as a car that has been dressed to look like one, and the difference can be a six figure one.

Fourth, think about what you want to do with the car. A numbers matching Chevelle SS 454 is a different ownership experience from a numbers matching Hemi ‘Cuda, because the platforms are different, the parts support is different and the market treats them differently. The Barracuda article itself says that the 1970 to 1974 E-body cars are collectible today, with high performance versions and convertibles commanding the highest prices, and that the small number of surviving cars is a result of low buyer interest and low production when they were new. If you are shopping, treat condition and authenticity as the price, not the badge.

The 1971 footnote: how fast things changed

It is worth noting how short this golden window was. The LS6 was announced for 1971 and then dropped. The Barracuda changed slightly in 1971 with a new grille and taillights, and it was the only year with four headlights and the only year of the fender gills on the ‘Cuda. The convertible was dropped after 1971, though a few late build 1971 convertibles with 1972 grilles and rear panels were supplied to Paramount Studios for television and film work, and were seen on shows such as Mannix and The Brady Bunch. Compression dropped, ratings moved to net figures, and the biggest engines of the muscle car era became a very short chapter. That is exactly why people still argue about 1970 more than almost any other year.

The verdict

On paper, the Chevelle SS 454 LS6 wins by 25 horsepower, 450 to 425, and it is the only one of the two with a published torque figure in the sources we used. On the street, the answer depends on the car in front of you, the tires on it and the person driving. The honest hardcore answer is that both are legends, and the real winner is whichever one you can authenticate, afford and actually enjoy. We would love to hear your side. Which one are you taking home, the Hemi or the LS6? Tell us in the comments, and follow Muscle Car Fan for more factory facts, rivalries and the occasional hot take.

Image credits: 1970 Plymouth Hemi ‘Cuda Ecurie Chrysler France.jpg by Mr.choppers (CC BY-SA 3.0) · Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 01.jpg by RL GNZLZ (CC BY-SA 2.0) · Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454 1970 02.jpg by RL GNZLZ (CC BY-SA 2.0). Facts from Wikipedia.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *