The Electric Charger Ran an 11.5-Second Quarter Mile — So Why Do Muscle Car Fans Say It’s Missing Something?

Edmunds put a 2025 Dodge Charger Daytona Scat Pack through a full test-track battery — three launch modes, a quarter mile in the 11-second range, braking, skidpad, and a dedicated range test — to answer one question: does an electric Charger actually deserve the name? The car’s Fratzonic exhaust system, built to fake a V8 soundtrack, gets its own verdict too. The results split the difference between genuinely quick and genuinely different.

An electric muscle car sounds like a contradiction until you actually put one on a test track and start recording numbers. Edmunds strapped their gear to a 2025 Dodge Charger Daytona Scat Pack — no V8, no exhaust note that isn’t manufactured by a speaker — and ran it through everything: a key-up launch, a max-settings launch, an optimized launch, and then a quarter mile. The numbers that came back settled an argument muscle car fans have been having since Dodge first announced this car existed. Whether they liked the answer is a different question entirely.

Three Launch Modes, Three Very Different Results

Edmunds didn’t settle for a single 0-60 run. Their test protocol included a key-up launch straight from park, a max-settings launch with every performance mode engaged, and a third optimized run designed to find the actual limit of the car’s launch control — a level of testing rigor that revealed how differently the Charger Daytona behaves depending on how deliberately its driver prepares for the run. The gap between the key-up number and the optimized number is where most owners will actually live, since almost nobody methodically dials in launch control before every stoplight.

⚑ Featured Gear

Start Car Conversations →

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

An 11.5-Second Quarter Mile Without a Single Gear Shift

The headline number from Edmunds’ testing was a quarter-mile run in the 11-second range, a figure that would have been considered a serious muscle car benchmark in any era, delivered here without a transmission shifting gears or an engine revving toward redline. Dual electric motors deliver their power instantly rather than building it through a powerband, which fundamentally changes what a quarter-mile run feels like from behind the wheel even when the elapsed time lands in genuinely quick territory.

Why ‘The Charger Is Huge’ Became Its Own Chapter of the Review

Edmunds gave the Charger Daytona’s sheer size and weight its own dedicated segment, and for good reason — the battery pack that gives this car its power also makes it dramatically heavier than any V8 Charger that came before it. That extra mass shows up everywhere in the test results, from straight-line acceleration to how the car behaves on the skidpad, where a heavier car fights physics harder than a lighter one no matter how much power is on tap.

The Fratzonic Exhaust: A Speaker Trying to Be a V8

Dodge’s Fratzonic Chambered Exhaust is the most controversial piece of engineering on this entire car — a sound system built into the rear of the vehicle that generates an amplified, exhaust-like note to replace the V8 sound this platform used to produce naturally. Edmunds ran a dedicated volume test on it, treating the system less like a gimmick and more like a genuine engineering question: can manufactured sound actually replace the emotional experience a real exhaust note used to deliver? Their answer, mixed at best, is part of why this review became a talking point across the muscle car community.

Braking and Skidpad Numbers Tell a Different Story Than the Quarter Mile

Straight-line acceleration is where electric powertrains have the biggest inherent advantage, but Edmunds’ braking and skidpad testing exposed where the Charger Daytona’s weight becomes a genuine liability rather than a footnote. A car this heavy asks more of its brakes and tires under repeated hard stops and cornering loads than a lighter gas-powered Charger ever did, and the test numbers reflect that tradeoff directly — this is a car that’s dramatically quicker in a straight line and measurably less composed everywhere else.

What the EV Range Test Revealed About Daily Usability

Beyond the performance numbers, Edmunds also ran a dedicated range test to answer the question every potential buyer actually cares about: how far can this thing go on a charge under real conditions, not just the EPA-rated figure on the window sticker. That test matters more for a muscle car than it would for a typical EV, since buyers cross-shopping this Charger against gas-powered alternatives are used to refueling in minutes rather than planning a charging stop into a road trip.

Does It Actually Live Up to the Charger Name?

Edmunds closed their testing with a direct verdict on the question every comment section has been arguing since this car was announced: does an electric powertrain deserve to wear the Charger badge at all? Their conclusion weighed genuinely quick acceleration numbers against a car that’s heavier, quieter in an authentic sense, and fundamentally different in character from every V8 Charger that came before it — a tension that this review doesn’t resolve so much as document in detail.

Why Dual Motors Change the Definition of a Muscle Car Launch

A V8 muscle car builds its quarter-mile time through a sequence of gear changes, each one a small interruption in power delivery that a skilled driver has to manage. The Charger Daytona’s dual-motor setup removes that variable entirely, sending peak torque to the wheels from a dead stop without any shift points at all, which is a large part of why its elapsed times stay so consistent between runs — there’s simply less for a human driver to get wrong.

What the Scat Pack Name Still Means on an Electric Car

Dodge carried the Scat Pack badge over from its gas-powered Charger and Challenger lineup specifically to signal that this electric variant sits at the performance end of the range, not the base trim — a branding decision that draws a direct line between this car and decades of Hemi-powered Scat Pack models. Whether that badge should carry the same weight on a battery-powered car is exactly the kind of question Edmunds’ testing was designed to help answer with data instead of just opinion.

Why Edmunds’ Track Data Matters More Than a Press Release

Manufacturer-claimed performance figures are optimized under ideal conditions, which is why independent test-track numbers like Edmunds’ carry more weight with serious buyers than anything printed on a spec sheet. Running the same key-up, max-settings, and optimized launch sequence that Edmunds uses across every vehicle it tests puts the Charger Daytona’s numbers in direct, apples-to-apples context against gas-powered muscle cars and other EVs alike, rather than letting the figures stand alone without a frame of reference.

Watch the full video and tell us what you think — comments are open below.