Why the 1970 Pontiac GTO 455 HO Lost to a Smaller Engine

Pontiac’s 455 HO had more cubic inches and more torque than the Ram Air 400, yet magazine testers clocked it slower through the traps. Here is why bigger was not faster.

Here is a fun way to start an argument at any car show: ask which 1970 Pontiac GTO was quicker, the one with the giant 455 cubic inch engine or the one with the smaller 400. Most people say the 455 without blinking. Bigger engine, more torque, easy win. The magazines of the day said something different, and the reason tells you a lot about how muscle car numbers really worked.

The rule that fell in 1970

For years, General Motors kept a corporate limit on engine size in its mid-size cars. The original 1964 GTO only existed because Pontiac’s team found a loophole: the limit applied to the standard engine, but a bigger engine could be sold as an option. So the GTO started life as a package on the LeMans, built around the 389 cubic inch V8 from the full-size Pontiac line. That bit of rule-bending is why the GTO sits where it does on any list of the Pontiacs that built the brand, and why every other GM division spent the rest of the decade trying to catch up.

By the 1970 model year, GM rescinded the ban on mid-size cars with engines larger than 400 cubic inches. Pontiac wasted no time. The GTO’s menu now included a new big option, the 455 HO, a long-stroke engine that Pontiac also sold in its full-size cars and in the Grand Prix. Chevrolet did the same thing the same year with the LS6 454 Chevelle, and Buick and Oldsmobile dropped their own 455s into the GS and the 442. For one season, every GM intermediate could be had with the biggest engine its division made.

⚑ Featured Gear
Start Car Conversations →

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The numbers on the window sticker

If you read only the factory ratings, the 455 HO looks strange. Pontiac listed it at 360 horsepower at 4,300 rpm, with a big 500 pound-feet of torque at just 2,700 rpm. The 400 cubic inch Ram Air engine sitting on the same option sheet was rated at 366 horsepower. So the bigger engine carried the lower horsepower number. And above both of them sat the Ram Air IV, the exotic one, with its own high-flow heads and intake, rated at 370 horsepower.

Why would Pontiac rate a bigger engine lower? Part of the answer is that gross power ratings from this era were not a clean scientific measurement. They were influenced by marketing and by internal GM policy, including a rule that tied advertised horsepower to a car’s curb weight. A rating was often a business decision as much as an engineering one. That is why car people love to say the numbers on paper are only the start of the story.

The ten-pound rule

That internal policy deserves a closer look, because it explains a lot of odd numbers from the era. GM management was nervous about insurance companies and safety critics, so it set an informal ceiling: an intermediate car should not advertise more than one horsepower for every ten pounds of curb weight. A GTO weighed in the neighborhood of 3,700 to 3,800 pounds depending on options, which put the ceiling right around 370 horsepower. Look again at the 1970 ratings. The Ram Air IV sat at exactly 370. The 455 HO at 360 and the Ram Air III at 366 slotted neatly underneath it.

Nobody at Pontiac was going to publish a figure that broke the corporate rule, so the published numbers tell you more about the policy than about the engines. Chevrolet’s 1970 LS6 454 at 450 horsepower was the famous exception, and it is one reason that engine still dominates conversations about Chevrolet’s finest muscle cars. Pontiac played it straighter, and its engines paid for that honesty with modest-looking ratings that undersold what they could do.

The surprise: same cam, different personality

Here is the detail that really matters. The camshaft in the Ram Air 400 and the camshaft in the 455 HO were the same. Even the manual transmission 455 HO engines used the same cam as the Ram Air 400. Same cam, bigger displacement, so you would expect the bigger engine to simply walk away.

That is not what the road testers found. Car and Driver tested a heavily optioned 455 HO with a four-speed and a 3.31 rear axle, and it ran the quarter mile in 15.0 seconds at 96.5 mph. Car Life tested a 455 with an automatic and a 3.55 axle, and it clocked 14.76 seconds at about 96 mph, with a 0 to 60 time of 6.6 seconds. Both cars finished about 3 mph slower through the traps than a Ram Air GTO with a four-speed.

Think about that. A bigger engine, with more torque, ran a lower trap speed than the smaller one. Trap speed is a decent stand-in for how much real power an engine makes at the top of the track, so the Ram Air engine’s high-rpm breathing was doing exactly what it was designed to do.

Why the heads made the difference

If the cams were the same, where did the gap come from? Mostly from the cylinder heads and the gearing. The 1970 455 HO used D-port heads, the same basic design as the Ram Air III, with a longer stroke underneath them. More stroke means more torque down low, but it also means the engine runs out of breath sooner at high rpm, because the same ports now have to feed a bigger cylinder. The Ram Air IV, by contrast, used round-port heads with much larger passages, a more aggressive cam, and an aluminum intake, so it kept pulling hard right to the shift point.

Gearing finished the job. The 455 HO was usually ordered with a relatively tall rear axle to suit its torque-rich character, which made the car relaxed on the highway but gave away a few tenths at the strip. The Ram Air cars came with shorter gears that let the engine stay in its happy zone. The long-stroke 455 was also simply heavier in the nose, and a GTO was already not a light car. Put those factors together and a smaller engine that breathes better and spins faster can post the better trap speed, even against a bigger engine with the same cam. In 1971, Pontiac fixed the breathing problem by putting round-port heads on the 455 HO, which is why the 1971 engine, despite a lower compression ratio and a lower rating, is often considered the best big-inch Pontiac of them all.

So why would anyone want the 455?

Because numbers on a timeslip are not the whole experience. Those same magazine tests tell us the Ram Air engine was temperamental. It idled roughly and was difficult to drive at low speeds. The testers described part-throttle driving around town as unpleasant, and they noted that the engine wanted to live between 3,000 and 6,000 rpm. Cruising on the freeway with deep gears was loud and busy.

The 455 HO was the opposite. Its torque arrived early, at 2,700 rpm, so the car pulled hard without needing to be wound up. It was far easier to live with, even if it was a few miles per hour slower at the end of the quarter mile. If you were a regular person driving your GTO to work on Monday, the 455 was the better car. If you were headed to a drag strip on Saturday, the Ram Air was the sharper tool.

There was even a fuel economy twist. The tests recorded fuel use of under 9 mpg for the smaller Ram Air engine, compared with roughly 10 to 11 mpg for the 455. Nobody bought a GTO for mileage, but the bigger engine was the thirstier-looking one that turned out to be less thirsty.

What the market thinks today

Collectors have cast their vote, and it mostly follows rarity rather than drivability. The Ram Air IV was built in small numbers for 1970, well under a thousand cars across hardtops, convertibles, and Judges, and a documented example commands the highest prices of any 1970 GTO. The 455 HO was ordered far more often, a few thousand cars, and sells for noticeably less, even though many owners will tell you it is the better engine to actually drive. The Ram Air III sits in between and is the sweet spot for a lot of buyers who want real performance without a seven-figure budget.

If you are shopping, verify the engine with the block code stamped on the front of the block and the date codes on the heads, because Ram Air clones are common and a 455 swapped into a base GTO is even more common. Where each version lands in the pecking order is a debate of its own, and our GTO kings countdown makes the case for how the 1970 engines stack up against the rest of the GTO family.

What this means for you

If you are new to old muscle cars, here are the lessons worth taking away from one little Pontiac comparison.

First, displacement is not destiny. How an engine breathes, how high it revs, and what gears sit behind it can matter as much as cubic inches. Second, factory horsepower ratings from this era are a starting point, not a verdict. Two engines can share a cam and still feel like completely different machines. Third, the best version of a car depends on what you actually want to do with it. A torque-rich cruiser and a high-rpm screamer can sit on the same showroom floor, wearing the same badge.

The 1970 GTO is also a reminder of timing. This was one of the last years when the big engines were allowed and the factory still had room to experiment. Within a few years, emissions rules, insurance costs, and lower compression killed off most of this menu. The window was short, and Pontiac used it to offer buyers a real choice between two very different kinds of fast.

Next time someone at a show tells you the 455 had to be the quicker GTO, you can smile and ask them about trap speeds. Then pick a side. Which would you rather own, the screaming Ram Air or the torquey 455 HO? Tell us in the comments, and do not be shy about it. Everybody at this party has an opinion.

Photo: 1970 Pontiac GTO Judge Ram-Air IV Coupe (54189218614).jpg by Ethan Long (CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *