Muscle Cars – Australia vs United States

Filmed for a Unique Cars magazine feature and aired on Australia’s Today Show back in November 2011, this video lines up American muscle against Australia’s own homegrown V8 legends – and the rivalry it sparked in the comments is still going strong. The Ford Falcon, a car Ford never officially sold in the U.S., squares off against the Mustang, while Holden’s VR Commodore SS and Chrysler’s Valiant Charger make the case for Australian engineering. So which country actually builds the better muscle car?

There’s a muscle car war that most Americans have never heard of, and it’s been fought on the other side of the world for decades. This footage, shot at a race track for a Unique Cars magazine story and later broadcast on Australia’s Today Show, puts American icons wheel to wheel with cars most U.S. enthusiasts couldn’t name. One of those cars was never even sold in the United States, official or otherwise. Another runs a straight-six engine wearing a name that sounds suspiciously like it belongs under a very different hood. The comments section has been arguing about which country actually builds the better muscle car for well over a decade now, and neither side shows any sign of backing down. Who’s actually right?

The Muscle Car War America Didn’t Know It Was Fighting

This video was originally produced for a Unique Cars magazine feature on best muscle car and aired as a segment on Australia’s Today Show on November 23, 2011, before being uploaded by channel madmaxmoviesTV and going on to rack up over 82,000 views. The premise is simple and effective: gather a spread of classic American and Australian muscle cars at a race track and let them make their own case side by side. What makes it more than a nostalgia reel is the framing-this isn’t American muscle held up as the unquestioned standard, it’s a genuine comparison with a national industry that developed its own performance V8 culture largely in parallel, and largely unknown to most U.S. audiences. Fifteen years after it aired, the video’s comment section is still one of the more entertaining places on the internet to watch that rivalry play out in real time.

⚑ Featured Gear

Start Car Conversations →

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Meet the Ford Falcon – The Muscle Car Ford Never Sold You

Front and center on the Australian side is the Ford Falcon, a nameplate that ran in Australia for generations while never being officially sold in the United States in this form-a detail that consistently surprises American commenters encountering the car for the first time. Australian Ford engineers took the Falcon platform in a distinctly local direction, building high-output performance variants tuned for Australian racing series and road conditions rather than importing decisions made in Dearborn. That divergence is exactly why the Falcon functions as such an effective conversation-starter in this video: it’s built by the same company that made the Mustang, wearing a name Americans might vaguely recognize, yet representing an entire performance lineage most U.S. muscle car fans have simply never had access to. It’s the clearest example in the video of how differently Ford performance evolved once it left American soil.

Holden’s Answer: Inside the VR Commodore SS

Representing Holden, and by extension General Motors’ Australian operations, is the VR Commodore SS-a locally engineered V8 sedan that Australian commenters hold up as a legitimate rival to anything Detroit was building in the same performance bracket. The Commodore SS lineage became Holden’s flagship performance answer through the 1990s, built around a V8 and tuned specifically for Australian touring car culture, which had its own deeply competitive racing scene independent of NASCAR or NHRA. For commenters arguing Australia’s case in this video, the VR Commodore SS often comes up as proof that a country roughly the population of Texas nonetheless sustained a full domestic performance car industry, engineering its own V8 sedans from the ground up rather than simply importing badge-engineered American product.

The Valiant Charger and Chrysler’s Forgotten Australian Chapter

The Valiant Charger adds a third thread to the story: Chrysler’s Australian division built its own two-door performance coupe distinct from anything sold under the Plymouth or Dodge banners in the U.S., aimed squarely at Australian touring car competition in the early 1970s. Commenters bring up the Charger specifically as evidence that all three major American manufacturers-Ford, GM, and Chrysler-ended up running semi-independent performance programs in Australia, each developing cars tailored to local racing series and market tastes rather than simply rebadging Detroit hardware. That the Charger, the Falcon, and the Commodore SS all trace back to American parent companies while looking and driving nothing like their U.S. cousins is part of what makes this video’s core comparison so much richer than a simple America-versus-everyone-else framing.

A 500-Horsepower Rumor: The Chevelle SS LS6 Everyone Argues About

On the American side, one car draws outsized attention in the comments: the 1970 Chevelle SS with the LS6 454 under the hood. One commenter, working from memory, claimed the LS6 Chevelle made close to 500 horsepower and over 550 lb-ft of torque straight from the factory-figures that, if taken at face value, would place it among the most powerful factory muscle cars of its era. That specific number should be treated as one enthusiast’s recollection rather than a verified factory spec, since official period ratings and modern dyno reassessments of the LS6 have varied depending on measurement standard and source. Verified or not, the claim alone is enough to explain why the 70 Chevelle SS still anchors the American side of this debate-it’s the car Australian commenters are implicitly measuring their own V8s against.

Straight-Six Muscle? The Curious Case of Australia’s 265 Hemi

Buried in the comments is a detail that trips up even seasoned muscle car fans: a reference to a 265 Hemi engine, which sounds like it should be an American big-block but almost certainly refers to Chrysler Australia’s own Hemi-6-a straight-six engine family, not a V8, that shared only a hemispherical combustion-chamber design and the Hemi name with its American V8 cousins. Chrysler Australia built and raced its own locally designed inline-six performance engines, a genuinely distinct engineering path from Detroit’s small-block and big-block Hemi V8s, and the naming overlap has confused casual viewers for years. It’s worth treating this detail loosely, since it surfaced as an aside in the comments rather than the video itself, but it’s a useful reminder that Hemi was never a single, universal engine-it was a combustion chamber design reused across continents in very different applications.

Where the European Ford Capri Fits Into a Very Global Story

A handful of commenters widen the conversation even further by bringing up the European Ford Capri as another historical alternative worth considering alongside the American and Australian entries. The Capri was Ford of Europe’s answer to the pony car format, sold across the UK and continental Europe through the 1970s and into the 1980s with a range of four- and six-cylinder engines aimed at a lighter, more nimble performance experience than either the Mustang or the Falcon offered. Its presence in the comment thread underlines just how global Ford’s performance-car strategy actually was during the muscle car era-Dearborn, Broadmeadows, and Cologne were effectively running three separate performance programs simultaneously, each shaped by local racing series and market demand rather than a single unified global platform.

Over a Decade Later, the Comments Section Is Still Fighting This Fight

More than a decade after this segment aired on Australian television, the comment section remains a genuinely lively example of good-natured national rivalry, with American and Australian viewers alike arguing for their own country’s muscle car heritage. What keeps the debate alive isn’t really about picking a winner-it’s that both sides are defending real, distinct engineering traditions rather than arguing over badge-engineered clones. The Falcon, the Commodore SS, and the Valiant Charger represent an entire parallel muscle car universe that developed largely out of view of American enthusiasts, while the Chevelle SS and Mustang represent the tradition most of the world still measures muscle cars against. That the argument is still going, more than a decade after the segment first aired, says something about how durable this particular rivalry has turned out to be.

Check out the full video above and let us know what you think in the comments.

Republished by Blog Post Promoter