A viral inspection video shows how close a fiberglass hood and a stripe kit came to fooling a buyer into paying six-figure money for a Mustang wearing a Shelby costume. The 1967 GT500 remains one of the most cloned muscle cars in the hobby — here is what actually separates the real ones from the fakes.
Somewhere out there right now, a seller is dressing up a Mustang fastback in Shelby stripes and a fiberglass hood, hoping a buyer falls in love before they check the numbers. It happens more often than most people realize, and it happened to the unsuspecting buyer at the center of a viral cautionary tale that has racked up over two million views. He thought he was driving home in a real 1967 Shelby GT500 — one of the most coveted muscle cars ever built. What he actually got was a lesson every classic car buyer needs to hear. The 1967 GT500 is rare, valuable, and exactly the kind of car con artists love to fake, which makes this story less of a one-off and more of a permanent warning label for anyone shopping this market.
The Video: A Real GT500 Clone Story
The video, from Gearhead Garage Inc, walks through the inspection of a car that looked, from ten feet away, like a legitimate 1967 Shelby GT500. It had the stripes, the hood scoops, the badges — all the visual shorthand buyers use to recognize a Shelby. But as the inspection gets closer, the cracks show. The channel’s own framing says it best: unscrupulous builders and sellers will “put lipstick on a pig” to get a buyer emotionally invested before the details come out. Fit, finish, and function all told a different story than the badges did, and the video walks through exactly how egregious the seller’s attempt to pass the car off as original really was.
What makes this video worth watching isn’t just the reveal — it’s the process. The presenter treats the inspection like a checklist, methodically working through the details a casual buyer would never think to check, and showing viewers what “buyer beware” actually looks like in practice on a six-figure classic. It’s a practical companion to the kind of pre-purchase inspection every serious buyer should be doing before money changes hands on a car like this.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Why the 1967 Shelby GT500 Gets Cloned So Often
The original GT500 arrived in 1967 as Carroll Shelby‘s answer to a simple problem: the smaller-block GT350 was a phenomenal handling car, but buyers increasingly wanted big-block muscle to go with the Shelby name. Ford obliged with the 428 cubic-inch Police Interceptor V8, officially rated around 355 horsepower — a figure most enthusiasts and period road tests agree was conservative. Shelby American built roughly 2,048 GT500 fastbacks and convertibles that first year, wrapped in a fiberglass nose, functional hood scoop, integrated roll bar, and sequential taillights borrowed from the Mercury Cougar.
That combination of scarcity and desirability is exactly why the GT500 has been a magnet for clones and “tribute” builds for decades. A genuine numbers-matching ’67 GT500 can trade for well into six figures, while a Mustang fastback with the right badges, stripe kit, and hood might cost a fraction of that to assemble. The gap between those two prices is where trouble lives — and it’s why VIN verification, Shelby American Automobile Club (SAAC) registry checks, and a qualified marque-specific inspector aren’t optional steps for a car like this. They’re the difference between owning a piece of muscle car history and owning a very expensive Mustang wearing a costume.
The name didn’t stop evolving after 1967, either, which adds another layer buyers need to keep straight. The GT500 continued through 1968 and 1969-70 with progressively wilder styling, was revived by Ford in 2007 on the S197 Mustang platform, and returned again in 2020 with a supercharged 5.2-liter V8 pushing over 750 horsepower. Each generation has its own known trouble spots and its own community of clone-spotters, but the first-year 1967 car remains the one most frequently faked, simply because it’s the one most collectors want most and the one with the fewest surviving originals to compare against.
What to Check Before You Buy One
If this story teaches anything transferable, it’s a short checklist worth keeping for any high-dollar classic muscle car purchase, not just a GT500. Start with the VIN — a real 1967 Shelby will carry a Shelby-specific VIN sequence, not a standard Mustang number with a fabricated tag riveted over it. Cross-reference that VIN against the SAAC World Registry, which tracks known GT500s and their ownership history. Then look past the paint: original fiberglass hoods, correct scoop shape, factory roll bar construction, and date-coded components all tell a story that reproduction parts can’t fully fake, especially once you know what to look for underneath.
Beyond the paperwork, this is where a marque-specific pre-purchase inspection earns its cost many times over. A generalist mechanic can tell you if the engine runs well; only someone who has inspected dozens of real Shelbys can tell you if the firewall stampings, chassis codes, and trim tag details actually belong on this specific car. Ask for build sheets, Marti Reports, and any documented ownership history — a car with real provenance will have a paper trail, and a seller who gets cagey when you ask for one is telling you something important all by itself. That’s the gap the buyer in this video fell into, and it’s the same gap that catches buyers every single year on GT500s, Hemi ‘Cudas, and any other muscle car valuable enough to be worth faking.
Watch the full video above and let us know your thoughts in the comments — and if you’re shopping for a classic Shelby of your own, take this one as your reminder to verify before you fall in love.
