Oh No! Was Buying A Famed Dodge Challenger Hellcat A Giant Mistake For This Dude?

Street Speed 717’s Mike spent eight months living with a 707-horsepower Hellcat before deciding to sell — and this video walks through exactly why, from dealer visits to tire costs. Commenters push back hard, defending the drivetrain while blaming the decals, and one distills the whole debate into a fast-cheap-reliable trilemma. See what eight months of real ownership actually revealed.

Somewhere between the dealership finance office and the moment he decided to sell, something changed Mike’s mind about the car everyone else assumed was a dream purchase. A 707-horsepower Hellcat should be the easy answer to “was it worth it,” but the host of Street Speed 717 spent this video walking through eight months of ownership, a dealer visit list long enough to make anyone nervous, and a supercharged V8 he still defends even while packing it up for sale. The blanket in the back seat is not what you think it is, and neither, it turns out, is his real reason for letting the car go.

Eight Months, One Blunt Question

Street Speed 717, hosted by Mike, built its following on unfiltered ownership content rather than manufacturer-sponsored press-car reviews — the channel covers daily-driven high-horsepower cars with the kind of warts-and-all honesty that dealership test drives never provide. This video’s description leans into that directness even in its title, framing the entire piece around a single blunt question: was buying the Hellcat a mistake? That is not the framing of a sponsored review; it is the framing of someone genuinely working through eight months of real ownership costs on camera.

⚑ Featured Gear

Start Car Conversations →

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

707 Horsepower and a Factory Warranty

The Hellcat name refers to the supercharged 6.2-liter Hemi V8 that Dodge dropped into the Challenger and Charger starting in the 2015 model year, rated at 707 horsepower from the factory — a number that, at the time, made it one of the most powerful mass-production American cars ever sold with a factory warranty. That warranty detail matters here specifically, because a chunk of this video’s tension comes from exactly how many times Mike says he visited the dealer during his ownership window, a list one commenter flagged directly: “8 months old and you have that laundry list of problems with that thing.”

The Real Cost of a Long Dealer Visit List

That same commenter raised a fair point about ownership economics: warranty repairs are free at the point of service, but the time cost of repeat dealer visits is its own kind of expense, one that does not show up on a monthly payment statement. “Going into the dealer that many times would drive me nuts,” the comment continues, “and wait until the warranty is up and they hand you a bill.” It is a pointed reminder that even a car that never costs the owner a repair invoice can still cost them something real in inconvenience.

Commenters Push Back: Blame the Decals, Not the Drivetrain

Not every commenter agreed the car was a mistake, however — several pushed back hard on the framing. “Buying the car wasn’t a mistake.. but those body decals were,” one wrote, drawing a distinction between the drivetrain, which multiple commenters defended as genuinely excellent, and the cosmetic trim package, which apparently drew more criticism than the supercharged engine ever did. Another added a track-day defense of the platform directly: “I agree, after driving these on track I can say that they handle much better than everyone gives them credit for,” pushing back on the Hellcat’s reputation as a straight-line-only muscle car with little cornering ability.

The Tire Bill Nobody Warns You About

The most consistently cited real expense, though, was tires. “I think the most expensive part of owning the Hellcat is keeping fresh rubber on the rear,” one commenter wrote, and it is a widely echoed complaint across Hellcat ownership content generally — 707 horsepower routed through a live rear axle chews through rear tires at a rate that can turn a routine maintenance item into one of the largest recurring costs of ownership, especially for an owner who actually uses the power rather than babying the throttle.

Fast, Cheap, Reliable — Pick Two

One commenter distilled the entire debate into a classic engineering trilemma, rewritten for muscle car ownership: “You can only pick two — Fast, Cheap, Reliable. If you want fast and cheap it won’t be reliable. If you want cheap and reliable it won’t be fast. If you want fast and reliable it won’t be cheap.” It is a joke, but it also doubles as the most honest possible summary of what a 707-horsepower daily driver actually demands from an owner who wants all three qualities at once and can only realistically get two.

The Blanket Wasn’t What Anyone Assumed

And then there is the blanket — the detail that pulled the most comments of all. Mike addressed it directly in a pinned response: it was there so his bulldogs could ride safely to their grooming appointments, not for whatever the comment section immediately assumed. That kind of unguarded, slightly absurd real-life detail is exactly what separates channels like Street Speed 717 from polished manufacturer content, and it is part of why an ownership video about warranty visits and tire wear still holds an audience’s attention for its full runtime.

Was It a Mistake, or Just a Mismatch?

Selling a Hellcat after eight months does not necessarily mean the car failed to deliver — it can just as easily mean an owner learned exactly what a 707-horsepower daily driver actually costs in tires, dealer visits, and attention, and decided that was not the ownership experience he wanted long-term. That distinction, between a car being a mistake and a car simply being a mismatch for a particular owner’s habits, is the real thread running through both the video and its comment section.

Why Early Hellcats Held Their Value Anyway

Despite the maintenance concerns raised throughout the video, early Hellcats have historically held their resale value remarkably well compared to typical American muscle — a combination of relatively low first-year production numbers, genuine factory-backed performance credibility, and rising enthusiast demand as later emissions and safety regulations made naturally aspirated and supercharged big-power V8s harder to keep in production. An owner selling an eight-month-old Hellcat in the mid-2010s was operating in a market where depreciation, unlike most new cars, was working in his favor rather than against him.

See the full video above and join the conversation in the comments.

Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Republished by Blog Post Promoter